r/AITAH 6d ago

AITAH for telling my daughter I won’t budge even if she never speaks to me again?

[removed]

18.7k Upvotes

23.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

166

u/Ok_Resource_8530 5d ago

$5 Says he and wife had something to do with Casey 'loaning' her sister the car too. I can hear it now 'we'll ground you from the car unless you share, you know your sister should be able to use the car' ect. Until she gave in. Don't be surprised when your oldest hates you all.

55

u/captainhyena12 5d ago

Funniest part is the only comment op left was a comment denying the allegations of them coercing the older daughter into letting the younger one drive the car. It's kind of odd that that was the only comment that struck a nerve enough for them to respond..... Kind of like it was the truth and that made OP mad 😂

8

u/Reallyhotshowers 5d ago edited 5d ago

It's probably technically true, but reality is something like "We did tell her that since we pay the insurance and paid for a portion of the car she was required to share the car when asked or she'd lose insurance and driving privileges. But no, we weren't part of this specific conversation where Alanna requested to borrow the car."

8

u/Ok-Cap-204 5d ago

“You are sisters! You need to share!”

4

u/Grimaldehyde 5d ago

Add in “ we paid for half and pay for the insurance on that car…”

1

u/Weightmonster 5d ago

That would be a different situation though